Breeder Guidelines for Optimal Behavioral Development in Puppies

Overview: Breeders play a crucial role in shaping a puppy’s temperament and behavior from birth. A combination of genetics, early environment, and guided socialization influences how puppies grow into well-adjusted adult dogs. The following guidelines outline general principles and stage-specific practices to foster optimal behavioral development, including special strategies for puppies that lack normal maternal care. Recommendations from veterinarians, animal behaviorists, and experienced breeders are integrated throughout, with scientific studies cited to support best practices.

1. General Principles of Puppy Behavioral Development

• Genetics and Breed Temperament: A puppy’s genetic makeup provides the foundation for its behavioral tendencies. Breeds and bloodlines differ in traits like fearfulness, sociability, and reactivity (Nature Vs. Nurture) (Nature Vs. Nurture). For example, classic experiments breeding “nervous” vs. stable Pointer dogs showed that fearfulness can be inherited, as pups from nervous lines remained more fearful even when fostered by calm mothers (Nature Vs. Nurture). However, genetics are not destiny – genes and environment “are inextricably bound together” in shaping behavior (Nature Vs. Nurture). Breeders should be mindful of inherited temperament traits and select breeding stock with stable, friendly temperaments when possible (Nature Vs. Nurture) (Nature Vs. Nurture).
• Maternal Influence and Prenatal Factors: The mother’s health, stress level, and caregiving behavior can have lasting effects on puppy development. Research suggests that the level of maternal care (nursing, licking, warmth) impacts pups’ adult engagement and stress resilience (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice). High-quality maternal care (as seen in attentive, calm dams) tends to produce puppies that are less anxious and aggressive (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice). Conversely, poor maternal behavior or high maternal stress (e.g. during pregnancy or whelping) may predispose pups to anxiety or cognitive delays (Maternal behavior in bitches | Vet Focus) (Maternal behavior in bitches | Vet Focus). Breeders should minimize stress for the pregnant bitch and provide a quiet, secure environment around whelping (Maternal behavior in bitches | Vet Focus). Close supervision is important in the first days postpartum to ensure the dam is caring for the litter and to intervene if she is not (Maternal behavior in bitches | Vet Focus).
• Early Environment and Handling: Environmental influences start from birth (and even in utero) and are “critical to behavioral development” in the neonatal and transitional weeks (Nature Vs. Nurture). Puppies raised in enriched, stimulus-rich environments develop into more confident and adaptable dogs than those from barren or isolated settings. Gentle early handling and mild sensory stimulation from the first days of life have proven benefits: studies found that puppies handled briefly each day from birth were less fearful and more exploratory as they grew up  (Nature Vs. Nurture). In one study, pups given daily handling from days 3 to 21 were significantly less afraid of novel stimuli at 8 weeks old compared to unhandled littermates . Breeders are encouraged to implement early neurological stimulation protocols (e.g. mild tactile, thermal, and positional exercises between days 3–16 of age) to improve stress tolerance and development (Nature Vs. Nurture). Importantly, any handling or early stimulation must be gentle and brief, always ensuring the neonates stay warm and are not distressed.
• Critical Socialization Period: Dogs have a sensitive window in early life when social and environmental experiences have a disproportionate impact on future behavior (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club) (Nature Vs. Nurture). This primary socialization period occurs roughly between 3 and 12 weeks of age  (Nature Vs. Nurture). During this time, puppies’ brains are highly receptive to forming social attachments and learning what is “normal” in their world. Positive exposures (meeting friendly people and animals, hearing household noises, exploring novel objects and surfaces) during this window tend to produce confident, well-adjusted adult dogs  . On the other hand, insufficient or negative experiences in this phase greatly increase the risk of fear, reactivity, and aggression problems later in life  ( AVSAB Position Statement On Puppy Socialization vs Waiting to Complete Immunization: Dog Gone Problems). In fact, behavioral issues stemming from poor early socialization are a leading cause of relinquishment or euthanasia in young dogs (far more so than infectious diseases) ( AVSAB Position Statement On Puppy Socialization vs Waiting to Complete Immunization: Dog Gone Problems) ( AVSAB Position Statement On Puppy Socialization vs Waiting to Complete Immunization: Dog Gone Problems). Because puppies begin life with more curiosity than fear (up until about 12 weeks, sociability outweighs wariness), breeders should capitalize on this window ( AVSAB Position Statement On Puppy Socialization vs Waiting to Complete Immunization: Dog Gone Problems). Intensive yet controlled socialization in the first 3 months is now considered standard of care by veterinary behavior experts (AVSAB Puppy Socialization Position Statement – Canine Welfare Science). Breeders should ensure each puppy has many safe, positive encounters with people, other dogs, and new environments well before 12 weeks old, in a way that does not overwhelm the puppy (see detailed steps below). Proper socialization can literally save lives by preventing serious behavior problems ( AVSAB Position Statement On Puppy Socialization vs Waiting to Complete Immunization: Dog Gone Problems) ( AVSAB Position Statement On Puppy Socialization vs Waiting to Complete Immunization: Dog Gone Problems).

Key takeaway: Genetics set the stage for a puppy’s personality, but early experiences determine how that potential is realized. With attentive maternal care, a rich and safe environment, and systematic socialization during the critical 3–12 week period, breeders can dramatically improve a puppy’s chances of growing into a confident, friendly dog  (Nature Vs. Nurture). The next sections provide step-by-step recommendations for each developmental stage.

2. Step-by-Step Recommendations by Developmental Stage

Breeding professionals should tailor their care and enrichment activities to the puppy’s developmental stage. Below are practical steps from birth through the neonatal, transitional, socialization, and juvenile periods to support healthy behavioral development.

Neonatal Stage (0–2 Weeks) – Newborn puppies: days 0–14

Newborn pups are completely reliant on their mother and have limited capacity to interact (blind, deaf, with only taste/touch senses functioning). The focus at this stage is on physical health and gentle early habituation:

• Ensure Maternal Care & Comfort: Allow the dam to bond with and care for her newborns with minimal disturbance in the first couple of days. Ensure the whelping area is warm, quiet, and stress-free so the mother can relax and tend to feeding and cleaning the pups (Maternal behavior in bitches | Vet Focus). Breeders should monitor that each puppy is nursing and that the dam is licking and cuddling them, as these maternal behaviors are vital for survival and neurological development (Maternal behavior in bitches | Vet Focus). If the litter is large, rotate pups to ensure smaller ones aren’t pushed away at nursing. Address any health issues promptly (consult a vet if pups fail to suckle or if the dam is agitated or neglectful).
• Gentle Daily Handling: Once puppies are a few days old and the mother accepts handling, begin brief daily handling sessions. Research indicates that puppies gently handled for just a few minutes per day from the first week of life cope better with stress and are less fearful later on  (Nature Vs. Nurture). A suggested practice is to start handling around Day 3 (as part of early neurological stimulation programs (Nature Vs. Nurture)). Each puppy can be lightly held and stroked for ~30 seconds to 1 minute, a few times a day . Include touching the pup’s head, ears, paws, and tail in a soothing manner   – areas that will be handled in routine care later (this helps puppies start habituating to human touch on all parts of their body). For example, gently run a finger along the puppy’s back from head to tail and tickle between the toes. Early handling can be combined with health checks like daily weighing   – e.g. place the pup on a scale, then reward by snuggling it against your warm body. Important: Keep handling sessions very short and positive; stop immediately if the puppy or the mother becomes distressed . Always wash hands and maintain clean conditions to avoid chilling the pup or exposing it to infection.
• Mild Sensory Stimulation: Apart from touch, breeders can introduce very mild forms of stimulation between days 3–16 to kick-start neurological development. This is often called Early Neurological Stimulation (ENS) or the “Bio Sensor” program. It involves simple exercises once per day such as holding the puppy in different orientations (upright, upside down) for a few seconds each, gently stimulating the feet with a cool, damp cloth, and briefly placing the pup on a cool surface before returning it to warmth. These gentle stressors, when done properly, stimulate the developing nervous system and have been linked to improved cardiovascular strength, stress tolerance, and faster maturation (Nature Vs. Nurture). For example, the U.S. military’s canine program reported that neonates given ENS later showed stronger heartbeats and greater resistance to stress than littermates without ENS (Nature Vs. Nurture). Breeders implementing these protocols should follow established guidelines (ensuring exercises are brief – 3 to 5 seconds each – and never pushing a puppy to the point of distress). Note: ENS is optional, but regular human touch and handling are essential at minimum.
• Maintain a Consistent Routine: Neonates thrive on routine. Keep lighting low to moderate (mimicking den conditions), and minimize loud noises during this stage (sudden loud sounds can cause startle or stress to the dam and indirectly the pups). It’s beneficial to speak softly when near the whelping box so puppies begin associating human voice vibrations with comfort. Daily routines (feeding times, cleaning) help puppies experience a predictable world early on.
• Health & Early Habituation: Use the neonatal period to gently habituate pups to very basic care activities. For instance, briefly examine each pup daily (check eyes closed, naval healing, etc.) so they experience being touched all over. If the dam allows, short periods of holding the pup in your hands or laying it on a different soft surface (like a towel on your lap) acclimate the neonate to micro-changes in environment while still feeling secure. Pups can also briefly smell new, safe scents (such as a unscented baby blanket that was in another room) to start engaging their developing noses. These subtle exposures lay the groundwork for adaptability. By the end of week 2, each puppy should be used to gentle human contact and routine handling in short doses  .

Transitional Stage (2–3 Weeks) – Awakening senses: ~Day 14 to Day 21

The transitional period is when puppies begin to see and hear (eyes typically open ~10–14 days; ears around 14–18 days) and start moving more purposefully. They transition from total helplessness to early learning. Key goals in this stage include continued gentle habituation and introduction of novel stimuli at a very low intensity:

• Continue Daily Handling and Increase Diversity: Keep up short handling sessions each day and begin to diversify the context. Around 2½ weeks, as pups become alert and responsive, introduce new people into the handling routine if possible. Up to 3 weeks of age, handling is mainly by the breeder or primary caretaker , but as the third week starts, invite additional gentle individuals (e.g. another family member or a trusted colleague) to pet and hold the puppies under supervision . Ensure all handlers have clean hands and calm demeanors. The puppies are still very impressionable, so all interactions must be gentle and positive (quiet voices, soft stroking). Early handling in the presence of the mother and littermates is ideal, so the pups feel secure . Gradually exposing pups to multiple humans at this stage primes them to accept people later – even before true socialization, they are forming associations. By the end of week 3, each puppy should have briefly encountered a few different people (males, females, perhaps an older child closely supervised), always with the mother dog nearby to keep them confident.
• Enrich the Physical Environment: As puppies gain mobility (wobbling on their legs by ~3 weeks), expand their world inside the whelping area. Provide an “interesting and enriching environment” in the puppy pen starting in this stage (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club). Introduce a variety of new objects and surfaces for pups to investigate once they are mobile. For example, place a couple of soft toys of different textures in the box (plush toy, crinkly fabric, chew-safe rubber item). You can also add a new surface inside the pen: by week 3, many breeders put down a potty area lined with different material (e.g. a low tray or shallow box with newspaper or puppy litter) separate from the sleeping area (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club). This not only jump-starts housetraining by leveraging the pups’ instinct to eliminate away from their sleeping spot, but it also introduces the feel of a new substrate. Similarly, you might temporarily lay a small carpet square or a piece of tile in the pen so puppies experience walking on carpet vs. smooth surface (always supervised and kept safe). Changing out one or two items each day (e.g. one day a plastic baby toy, next day a cardboard tube) gives puppies something novel to see, smell, and paw at (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club). Note: Items must be large enough not to be swallowed and free of sharp edges. The idea is to gently stimulate curiosity during this low-fear period.
• Introduce Mild Sounds and Startle Recovery: Between 3 and 4 weeks old, puppies begin to respond to sounds. This is an optimal time to introduce everyday noises in a controlled manner, because at this age puppies have very little fear response (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club). Breeders can take advantage of this by gently “startling” the pups with novel noises followed by positive outcomes. For example, around week 3, you can make soft noises near the litter: clap your hands quietly, jingle keys, ring a bell, or crinkle a paper bag. The puppies may startle momentarily, but if you then speak happily or offer your hand to sniff, they quickly recover and learn that strange sounds are not harmful. As they approach 4 weeks, you can increase the variety and volume of noises: drop a lightweight book on the floor, close a door, run a vacuum cleaner in the next room, or play a CD of sound effects at low volume (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club). Each time, observe that the puppies either don’t react or startle only briefly, then return to normal behavior. This startle–recovery training builds resilience. Jane Killion, a breeder and trainer behind the “Puppy Culture” program, advocates such exercises at this stage when puppies are naturally fearless (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club). She notes that surprises (like a dropped pan or a vacuüm starting) are “very good occurrences at this age” to help pups develop a robust recovery from sudden stimuli (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club). Always keep intensity appropriate – loud noises should be brief and not so close as to terrify. The goal is controlled exposure: for instance, turn on the vacuum across the room for a few seconds while the puppies are feeding so they associate it with a positive activity, then turn it off.
• Short Individual Sessions: Begin gently separating each puppy from the litter for very short periods (1–2 minutes to start) to build independence and comfort being alone. Around the end of the 3rd week, take one pup at a time just a few feet away from the rest (within the mother’s sight) and engage with it – let it smell you, cuddle it, maybe offer a taste of a canine milk replacer on your finger. Then promptly reunite it with the litter. These micro-sessions teach the puppy that being alone with a human is safe and fun, reducing the shock when they eventually leave the litter. By 4 weeks, pups can handle slightly longer solo outings (5 minutes) for things like weighing, grooming, or play (as detailed in the next section) .
• Support Emerging Abilities: Encourage the puppies’ clumsy attempts at play and exploration. At 2–3 weeks they will start interacting with littermates – play-biting, climbing on each other, etc. Ensure the play area is safe for these explorations (no steep drop-offs or harmful objects). Breeders can get down at puppy level and let pups crawl on them, mouth fingers (you can redirect mouthing to a toy). This starts teaching bite inhibition as littermates and humans yelp or withdraw if a pup bites too hard. Additionally, continue daily routines like gentle brushing (with a soft toothbrush or cloth) and touching all over the body, which by now puppies will respond to with wriggles and interest. By the end of this stage, puppies should be able to see and hear well, follow movement, and display curiosity – setting the stage for full socialization.

Socialization Stage (3–12 Weeks) – Critical Socialization Period: Weeks 4 through 12

This is the most influential phase for shaping a puppy’s behavior. From the 4th week onward, puppies rapidly develop social skills and gain the capacity to form lasting positive or negative associations. Breeders should treat weeks 4–8 (while pups are still in their care) as an intensive socialization boot camp, and also guide new owners to continue the process through 8–12 weeks and beyond. Key recommendations during this period:

• Keep Puppies with Litter and Mother Until 7–8 Weeks: Maintain the litter as a group with the dam for at least the first 7 weeks (most breeders keep puppies until 8 weeks or a bit longer). I recommend a minimum age of 8 weeks and 4 days [60 days old]: the extra 4 days has been shown to reduce the risk of later separation anxiety developing.  This is crucial because during weeks 4–7 puppies learn species-specific social skills from their mother and siblings (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club) (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice). Through play fighting and feedback from littermates, they develop bite inhibition and learn how to communicate and cooperate with other dogs (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club) (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice). The mother also continues to discipline them gently (e.g. a growl or muzzle hold if a puppy bites too hard) and provides comfort and confidence as they explore. Research by Scott & Fuller and others confirms that puppies left with littermates through ~7 weeks have better social adjustment than those separated too early (Nature Vs. Nurture). Early separation (e.g. at 4–6 weeks) is linked to higher risk of behavior problems like anxiety and biting (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice). Thus, do not wean or rehome puppies before 7 weeks, except in extreme circumstances. The ideal time to send a puppy to its new home is about 8 weeks old, when it is past the peak of the critical period but before the window starts to close (Nature Vs. Nurture) (and when the puppy is weaned, vaccinated, and developmentally ready to form new attachments).
• Socialization and Habituation Plan: As a breeder, create a socialization plan covering weeks 3–12 and implement it daily. A written plan or checklist helps ensure each puppy gets a wide range of positive experiences without overdoing it. The plan should outline exposures by week (for instance, Week 4: introduce collar, Week 5: car ride, etc.) and track each pup’s progress . Critical elements to include:
  • Exposure to Different People: Aim to have each puppy meet at least 10–20 new people (of varying age, gender, appearance) by 8 weeks of age. More is better – one study found that puppies who encountered 20–30 different people during the socialization period were more confident as adults (Pluijmakers et al. 2020).  This is why I recommend that all breeders hold a “Puppy Open Day” when puppies are just over 7 weeks old [following formal puppy temperament testing and matching to their most compatible owners].  These interactions should be gradual, positive, and gentle. Invite a diversity of visitors (men with beards, women, children, people with hats or glasses) to handle and play with the puppies under supervision . Supervise children closely; teach them to sit and let puppies approach, to avoid rough handling or scaring the pups. Each puppy’s response should guide the interaction – if a pup appears fearful (e.g. cowering or retreating), let it observe from a safe spot and encourage the person to offer treats and let the pup approach at its own pace . Never force a frightened puppy into someone’s arms, as that can backfire. By the time of homing at 8–10 weeks, a puppy should be very familiar with human touch and have a positive association with meeting new people (willing to wag tail and engage).
  • Surface and Object Enrichment: Continue to broaden the puppies’ physical world. Provide a variety of surfaces to walk on: grass, carpet, wood, tile, plastic tarp, gravel, etc. (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club) (Socialization – Part 3: People, Places and Things — Heather Pope). By 7 weeks a pup should have walked on at least seven different types of flooring/surface (often called the “Rule of Sevens” in socialization) (Socialization – Part 3: People, Places and Things — Heather Pope) (Socialization – Part 3: People, Places and Things — Heather Pope). Also introduce puppies to novel objects and obstacles: tunnels to crawl through, a wobble board or unstable surface (low to ground) to gain balance, different types of toys (hard ball, soft plush, squeaky toy, cardboard box, etc.). Changing the toys and objects every day or two keeps the environment novel (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club). These experiences during 4–8 weeks help the puppies develop confidence with new textures and sights, reducing the chance they’ll be afraid of strange surfaces or household items later in life (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club). Tip: An easy enrichment technique is to create a “sensory play box” – e.g. a shallow box or kiddie pool with safe items like plastic bottles, rope toys, rustling paper, and let puppies explore under supervision. Always ensure items are safe (no choking hazards) and remove anything that causes distress.
  • Sounds and Noises: Build on the noise desensitization from week 3 by progressively introducing louder or more varied sounds in weeks 4–8. The key is controlled, gradual habituation. For example, around 5 weeks, play a socialization sounds CD or playlist (many breeders use recordings of city noises, thunderstorms, babies crying, etc.) at a low volume during puppy playtime or feeding . Over days, slowly increase the volume if the puppies show no fear. You can also expose pups to real household noises: run a vacuum cleaner in the same room briefly, clang pots in the kitchen, ring the doorbell, run the washing machine. Pair these sounds with positive events, like feeding or play, so the puppies form happy associations . If a pup startles, keep calm and act cheerful to signal there’s no danger. By 8 weeks, puppies that have heard a broad range of noises (engines, doorbells, music, etc.) in a positive context will be far less likely to develop noise phobias  . Always avoid flooding – do not trap puppies in a situation with a scary noise hoping they “get used to it,” as this can make fear worse . Instead, use desensitization: low-level exposure coupled with rewards, and gradually increase intensity over sessions .
  • Handling and Grooming: Intensify handling exercises so puppies are comfortable with all sorts of physical contact. Continue daily gentle handling, increasing duration as they age . By 5–6 weeks, each pup can be held and examined for a few minutes at a time. Practice “vet-style” handling: look in ears, open the mouth gently to touch teeth, rub belly, hold each paw and apply slight pressure between toes, lift the tail. Intermix this with treats or petting so it’s pleasant. Breeders can trim nails carefully around 6 weeks, brush the coat lightly, and simulate procedures like wiping the eyes or inspecting under the tail. This prepares pups for real vet exams and grooming. According to one guide, puppies handled extensively (including gentle restraint and paw touches) adapt better to future husbandry needs  . Collar acclimation should also happen now: put an appropriate-size flat collar on puppies for short periods starting ~5 weeks . Initially they may scratch at it; distract them with play. Gradually extend collar-wearing so that by 8 weeks they are comfortable in a collar . Similarly, introduce a lightweight crate or carrier in their area as a cozy den – drop treats inside so puppies venture in and out freely. By 7–8 weeks, do short practice of closing a pup in the crate with a chew toy for a few minutes to build tolerance (never use the crate as punishment). These steps ensure the transition to new homes (where crates, collars, vet visits are inevitable) is smoother.
  • Toilet Training Foundations: Capitalize on puppies’ natural tendency around 3–4 weeks to eliminate outside their sleeping area (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club). Starting at week 3, maintain a designated “potty zone” (such as a low pan with wood pellets or newspaper) in the pen, separate from the bedding area. Gently place puppies on the pan after waking or eating so they associate it with toileting. By 5–6 weeks, if weather permits and disease risk is managed, introduce the pups to an outdoor toileting area (secure yard)  . Take them outside frequently (at least every 2–3 hours during the day). Reward them with praise when they eliminate outdoors. This early routine will give new owners a head-start on housebreaking. Puppies can learn to use a dog door or to signal at the pen door by 7–8 weeks when this habit is ingrained. A note from the EU socialisation guidelines: puppies as young as 5 weeks should have daily access to an outdoor, safe area for at least 30 minutes (weather permitting), to exercise, play, and toilet  . Make sure the outdoor area is secure and clean (no exposure to unvaccinated dogs) and supervise at all times.
  • One-on-One Training and Play: Starting around week 5, incorporate short individual play/training sessions with each puppy daily . These sessions (5–10 minutes per pup) are invaluable for building the puppy’s bond with humans and introducing basic commands. Use a variety of toys to engage the puppy – play tug, roll a ball, play chase-and-run in a safe fenced space. During these interactions, practice simple reward-based training: call the puppy by name and reward when it comes; encourage it to sit by holding a treat above its nose and praise when its rear hits the ground. Keep it fun and light – if the pup loses interest, just play. Even at 6–7 weeks, pups can start learning cues like “come” and “sit” with gentle guidance and treats  (Socialization – Part 3: People, Places and Things — Heather Pope). Teaching a default “sit for attention” (instead of jumping or nipping) is a great foundation – reward the pup whenever it sits calmly. These mini training games build the puppy’s confidence and mental stimulation. They also help identify individual temperaments (some pups may be bolder or more attentive while others are distractible, which is useful information for matching to new owners).
  • Novel Locations and Car Rides: While keeping vaccination status in mind, try to give pups a taste of different environments beyond their immediate home. This could be as simple as moving the puppies to a different room or part of the yard regularly. For example, let them play in the kitchen one day, in a safely enclosed porch the next – so they don’t only know the whelping room. Each new area offers new smells and sights. Additionally, prepare puppies for travel before they go to their new homes. Starting around 6–7 weeks, introduce them to a pet carrier or crate in a car. Initially, place a pup (or a couple of littermates together) in a carrier and just sit in a stationary car giving treats. Next, take very short drives (5–10 minutes), ensuring the puppies are secure and comfortable (use soft bedding and perhaps a familiar toy)  . Keep drives positive – perhaps end at a fun destination like a friend’s yard for a short play, or simply return home and give a meal. The goal is that the puppy’s first car ride is not the stressful trip to the veterinarian or the long ride to its new home; instead it’s already a familiar routine. By 8 weeks, each puppy should have had a few car rides and be reasonably calm in the car (no frantic whining or vomiting). Also practice being alone: by occasionally having one puppy separated (in a crate in another room for a few minutes), you reduce extreme dependency on littermates and help the upcoming transition to a single-puppy household.
• Monitor and Adapt: Throughout the socialization process, observe each puppy’s reactions and adjust accordingly. Keep a socialization diary for each pup – note what new experience was introduced and the pup’s response (e.g. “Day 45: introduced to toddler – puppy was curious and wagging” or “Week 7: first bath given – puppy was nervous, wiggled, but calmed with gentle talking”). If a puppy shows consistent fear to a particular stimulus, take extra care to reintroduce that stimulus more slowly and with plenty of positive reinforcement. For instance, a pup cowering from the vacuum might benefit from hearing a lower-volume recording of a vacuum while being held and fed treats, before experiencing the real thing again. The principle is to never overwhelm the puppy beyond its coping ability . Let the puppy set the pace – one pup might confidently climb stairs at 7 weeks, while a more timid littermate may need another week and encouragement. Carefully planned socialization during this sensitive stage will yield puppies that approach new situations with curiosity rather than fear  .
• Preparing for Transition to New Homes: As puppies near the end of the primary socialization period (8–12 weeks), breeders should proactively prepare them and their future owners for a smooth handover. Around 7–8 weeks, start gradually weaning puppies off constant littermate company to prevent severe separation distress later. For example, have them spend nap times in pairs or alone rather than the whole litter pile every time. Continue increasing the time they can be crated individually (always with a positive activity like chewing a treat). Provide a “scent blanket” for each puppy to take home – a cloth rubbed on the mother and littermates – to comfort them in their new environment (scent is a powerful stress-reducer for pups).
• Educate new owners about the critical nature of ongoing socialization: give them a checklist of experiences to continue (meeting new people, noises, puppy classes, etc.) and emphasize that the socialization period extends to about 12–16 weeks. In the Elite Breeder Formula program training includes a Puppy Handover Day protocol to ensure proactive education for all new puppy owners.  Encourage owners to enroll in puppy socialization classes as early as 8–10 weeks (once the puppy has initial vaccinations) – veterinary behaviorists note that the risk of illness is small relative to the risk of missed social learning (AVSAB Puppy Socialization Position Statement – Canine Welfare Science) ( AVSAB Position Statement On Puppy Socialization vs Waiting to Complete Immunization: Dog Gone Problems). By implementing all the above steps, breeders will have given each puppy a robust foundation. Puppies will leave for their new homes confident with people, unafraid of common noises, comfortable being handled, and with budding house-training and basic manners.

Juvenile Stage (3–6+ Months) – Ongoing Development in the New Home

By 12 weeks and older, puppies enter a juvenile period and are usually in their permanent homes. While breeders may no longer have direct control at this stage, it’s important to provide guidance to new owners so the puppy’s behavioral development stays on track:

• Continued Socialization: Stress to owners that socialization is not “finished” when the puppy leaves the breeder. The period from 3 to about 6 months is sometimes called the secondary socialization or juvenile period, and puppies still benefit greatly from new experiences to reinforce the positive exposures they had earlier. In fact, without continued exposure, even a well-socialized 8-week-old can regress and become fearful . Breeders should encourage owners to safely introduce the puppy to many more people, dogs, places, and stimuli in the coming weeks. Puppy kindergarten classes (for vaccinated pups under 5 months) are highly recommended as they provide controlled social play and training with other dogs and people. The American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior states puppies can start classes as early as 7–8 weeks (after initial vaccines and health check) and that these classes are an excellent way to continue socialization through the juvenile period ( AVSAB Position Statement On Puppy Socialization vs Waiting to Complete Immunization: Dog Gone Problems) ( AVSAB Position Statement On Puppy Socialization vs Waiting to Complete Immunization: Dog Gone Problems). Owners should aim to keep building positive experiences – e.g., meeting friendly dogs of various sizes, supervised playdates with well-mannered adult dogs, visits to different environments like parks, pet-friendly stores, etc. This ongoing socialization helps prevent the onset of fear behaviors that could otherwise appear as the pup matures.
• Training and Mental Stimulation: Puppies are like sponges for learning up until about 6 months, so owners should be coached to take advantage of this. A well-behaved dog is less likely to be rehomed, so training is part of ensuring long-term behavioral wellness. Reputable breeders often send puppies home with a “puppy packet” of training tips. Suggest that owners use positive reinforcement methods to teach basic obedience (sit, down, stay, come, leash walking) and to continue practicing handling (so the pup stays comfortable with grooming and vet exams). Regular play and exercise appropriate to the pup’s age are critical to channel energy and develop motor skills. Breeders can emphasize puzzle toys, chew toys, and short training games as ways to provide mental enrichment and prevent problem behaviors from boredom.
• Navigating Fear Periods: Many puppies undergo one or more “fear periods” during juvenile/adolescent development (often around 8–10 weeks and again ~6–9 months, though timing varies). During these times, a puppy might suddenly become wary of things it was fine with before. Breeders should alert new owners that if their pup seems fearful all of a sudden (e.g. cowering from strangers at 4 months old), they should handle it with patience and kindness – do not punish or force the pup in those moments. Instead, back up to easier exposures and gently rebuild confidence with treats and praise. Knowing about this possibility can help owners avoid inadvertently cementing a fear. Early extensive socialization usually blunts the impact of fear periods, but awareness is key.
• Support and Resources: Good breeders remain a resource for puppy buyers. Encourage owners to stay in touch and ask questions about behavior. If any issues arise (excessive fear, separation anxiety, puppy biting), breeders can refer them to certified trainers or veterinary behaviorists for early intervention. It’s far better to address problems at 4–5 months than to let them worsen. By providing this continuity of care, breeders reinforce the importance of behavioral development beyond their direct influence and increase the likelihood of a successful lifelong match between puppy and owner.

In summary, while the juvenile stage is primarily the new owner’s responsibility, breeders set the puppy up for success and can guide the owners in maintaining the momentum. This teamwork ensures that the puppy continues the positive trajectory established in its first weeks of life.

3. Special Considerations for High-Risk Puppies

Not all puppies have the benefit of a normal upbringing with their dam and litter. Orphaned, hand-reared, rejected, and Caesarean-delivered puppies require special care to mitigate their higher risk of behavioral issues. Breeders should employ extra strategies to support these pups’ emotional development:

Hand-Reared, Orphaned, or Rejected Puppies

(A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice) Figure: A surrogate adult dog nuzzling an orphaned neonate being bottle-fed. Hand-reared puppies greatly benefit from exposure to gentle adult dogs who can provide some maternal behaviors (licking, warmth, social interaction) that humans alone cannot fully replicate. (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice) (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice)

Puppies raised without their mother (and, in the worst case, without littermates) are at a significant developmental disadvantage. Studies show that puppies separated from the dam too early are more likely to develop anxiety, reactivity, and aggression problems as adults (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice). They also tend to have higher stress hormone levels and may lack proper dog-to-dog social skills. To improve outcomes for hand-reared or orphan pups, consider these strategies:

• Foster with Canine “Surrogates”: Whenever possible, the best solution is to have orphaned pups nursed and cared for by another lactating female (a foster dam) or at least socialized by a gentle adult dog. “The best-case scenario for orphaned puppies is, without question, to foster with a post-partum dam,” advises veterinary behaviorist Laura McAuliffe (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice). If a foster nursing mother is available (through breed clubs, shelters, or networking), carefully introduce the orphaned pups to her, ensuring she accepts them and has enough milk. Even if she cannot nurse them fully, simply having a canine adult to cuddle and clean them is immensely beneficial. Many adult bitches (and even neutered males in some cases) will “adopt” young puppies by licking, snuggling, and supervising them (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice) (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice). This provides critical tactile stimulation and teaches the pups how to communicate with an adult dog. If a lactating foster isn’t found, an alternative is a canine foster family – i.e., raise the puppy in a home with one or more stable, dog-social adult dogs who can interact with the puppy under supervision (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice) (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice). For example, a calm adult dog in the household can serve as a teacher and playmate once the orphan pup is mobile. Foster “aunt/uncle” dogs often help by grooming the pup (stimulating urination/defecation in neonates by licking, similar to a mom) (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice) and disciplining when needed, thereby filling some gaps left by the missing dam.
• Simulate Maternal Care: When human caretakers must raise the pup, they should mimic the mother dog’s functions as closely as possible. This includes: providing warmth (e.g. heat source and soft bedding to snuggle), feeding on a schedule (bottle-feeding with appropriate milk replacer every 2–3 hours for neonates), and stimulating elimination (rubbing the genital area with a warm moist cloth to trigger urination/defecation, as the mother would with her tongue). Beyond basic survival care, mimic the mother’s nurturing behaviors: frequently stroke and caress the puppies all over with a soft cloth or your hand to substitute for maternal licking. This kind of tactile stimulation is vital for development. If the pup is a singleton (no littermates), provide plush stuffed toys or rolled towels in the bed so the pup has something to cuddle with and crawl over, reducing loneliness and aiding muscle development. Some breeders use a ticking clock or a heartbeat simulator toy to emulate the soothing sound of littermates or mom. Additionally, offer outlets for suckling if the puppy shows frantic nursing behavior – provide a safe pacifier (like a pet nurser nipple or even your clean finger) for the pup to suck on between feedings (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice). Suckling is a comfort behavior, and denying an orphan this can lead to oral fixations or stress. As the pup grows, ensure it has appropriate chew toys to satisfy mouthing urges.
• Intensive Socialization with Dogs: One of the biggest challenges for hand-reared pups is learning dog social skills, since they lack normal interactions with mom and littermates. Starting as early as 3 weeks (once the orphan pup can see/hear and move), it is crucial to socialize the puppy with other dogs. If the pup has no littermates, arrange supervised play sessions with a vaccinated, puppy-friendly dog. Ideally, use a stable adult dog that is known to be gentle with puppies – this dog will teach the orphan boundaries and communication. McAuliffe notes that singleton puppies should be fostered with stable adult dogs so they “learn how to communicate, play and behave appropriately” around their own species (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice) (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice). For example, an adult will gently correct a biting puppy, teaching bite inhibition, and will model appropriate dog body language. Size matching is important: use adult dogs close in size or very tolerant of tiny pups to prevent accidental injury (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice) (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice). If there’s a size disparity, employ “protected contact” – e.g., let them interact through a puppy play pen or gate, or closely supervise short sessions on the floor with the puppy able to retreat to a safe area (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice) (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice). As the orphan pup grows, also arrange meetings with other puppies of similar age (puppy playdates or training classes) so it learns peer-to-peer play. These interactions during the 3–12 week window are absolutely critical; without them, a hand-raised dog may not learn to read dog social cues, leading to fear or aggression with other dogs later. Even scent exposure can help – for instance, bring a blanket that other dogs have slept on (no detergent) and let the pup smell it (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice). This introduces the puppy to the odor of other dogs and can ease eventual face-to-face meetings.
• Preventing Hyper-Attachment: Human-reared puppies often become too attached to their caregiver, since that’s their only social partner. To avoid severe separation anxiety, expose the pup to multiple people early on (once immune system allows) so it doesn’t imprint on one person exclusively. Encourage other family members or friends to feed, play, and handle the puppy regularly. Also practice short separations from the primary caregiver even while the pup is young, so it learns to self-soothe. For example, have the pup spend time in a playpen with toys while you leave the room for a few minutes, gradually increasing duration. Leaving a radio or white noise can help the pup feel it’s not completely alone. Teaching a structured nap or bed time in a crate will also foster independence.
• Manage Weaning and Suckling Needs: Hand-reared puppies often struggle with weaning because they find nursing (from a bottle or human) very comforting. Weaning should be done gradually and later than typical if possible, to reduce stress. Studies suggest that abruptly weaning too early can cause long-term behavior issues (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice). In free-living dogs, natural weaning occurs around 11–13 weeks (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice), much later than the 6–8 weeks in controlled breeding. Therefore, for an orphan singleton, you might continue supplemental bottle feedings longer while introducing gruel slowly, to allow a more natural pace of weaning without sudden frustration. This extra effort can help prevent oral compulsive behaviors or excessive suckling on objects (or themselves).
• Enriched Environment: Because a singleton or orphan pup doesn’t have siblings to play with, the human caregiver must provide an especially rich environment to keep the pup’s developing brain occupied. Give the puppy a wide range of toys and rotate them often. Engage in lots of play with the pup to tire it out (games of fetch, tug, hide-and-seek with a toy). Start early training (sit, come, etc.) to channel the pup’s energy into learning. A bored, isolated puppy is likely to develop anxieties or destructive habits.
• Careful Placement and Follow-Up: Recognize that despite best efforts, hand-raised puppies may be more prone to behavioral quirks (they might be “needy,” mouthy, or lacking bite inhibition). It is wise to place such puppies with experienced, patient owners, ideally in homes that already have a calm, well-socialized dog to continue teaching the pup (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice) (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice). The presence of an older “mentor” dog in the adoptive home can greatly help a singleton adjust and learn normal dog behavior. Breeders should fully inform new owners of the puppy’s unusual start and encourage them to work with a trainer or behaviorist early. Proactive support (puppy classes, socialization outings, etc.) will be crucial. With extra care, even orphaned pups can grow into well-adjusted companions, but the socialization and training must be taken very seriously by all involved.

Caesarean-Born Puppies

Puppies delivered via C-section present a different set of challenges. The primary concern is that the dam’s maternal instincts may be delayed or impaired due to the lack of natural labor and hormonal surges associated with birthing. This can lead to the mother being initially confused or unattached to her puppies, which in turn can affect the puppies’ care and early social bonding. To ensure C-section puppies get the best start:

• Facilitating Maternal Bonding: A bitch recovering from anesthesia might not immediately recognize or accept her newborns. Breeders should introduce puppies to the dam carefully and supervise constantly until she shows stable maternal behavior (Maternal behavior in bitches | Vet Focus). Right after delivery, rub the puppies with some of the mother’s placental fluids (if available) or simply gently place them at her teats as she wakes, to trigger her grooming and nursing instincts. Be prepared to intervene if she shows aggression or disinterest – in some cases a C-section dam may even pose a risk of harming pups if she’s disoriented. Keep the puppies warm (use warming devices) until the dam is fully awake and attentive, since she may not immediately curl around them. Once the mother begins licking and nursing, monitor that she is doing so adequately. Do not leave a post-Caesarean dam alone with puppies for the first day or two until certain she has accepted them and won’t inadvertently harm or neglect them (Maternal behavior in bitches | Vet Focus). Most bitches come around with a bit of time and encouragement – the key is intensive observation and support.
• Supplemental Care: Because some C-section mothers have delayed milk let-down or lower initial maternal care, the breeder should be ready to step in with partial hand-rearing techniques for the first 24–48 hours. This might include bottle-feeding puppies if they are not nursing well, helping them eliminate, and keeping them warm and clean if the dam isn’t yet doing so. Often, once the dam’s hormones catch up and she takes interest, she will fully assume care. But if not, the litter may need to be managed similarly to orphan pups (see above). Sometimes a dam will nurse but not groom; in that case, you might let her nurse but you take on the cleaning of puppies after feeds. Flexible responsiveness is key.
• Stress Management for the Dam: Ensure the environment is very calm for the C-section mother. Pain or confusion can make her more likely to reject pups, so follow vet guidance on pain control for the dam. Keep her on a regular schedule of analgesics so she’s comfortable feeding. Reduce external stressors (no unnecessary visitors, loud noises, or other pets bothering her) in the first few days. This will help her maternal instincts kick in. A stressed mother might inadvertently transmit anxiety to puppies or simply not engage in much interaction, which can affect the puppies’ emotional development. Thus, create a serene, private space for the new family.
• Compensate for Lost Natural Stimuli: The birth process itself provides certain stimuli to puppies – the compression during passage through the birth canal and immediate intense licking by the mother. In C-section pups, these are absent or delayed. Breeders can somewhat compensate by thoroughly rubbing each newborn pup with a warm towel immediately after delivery to simulate the stimulation of labor and maternal licking. This helps clear lungs (as the vet likely does) and gives tactile activation. Continue frequent handling (as described in neonatal care) to ensure C-section pups get plenty of touch. Basically, all the earlier recommendations about early handling apply even more so, since the mother might not lick or handle them as much initially. Some breeders also note that C-section pups can be slightly more lethargic at first (due to anesthesia effects); gentle stimulation (rubbing, talking to them) can encourage normal vigor.
• Socialization Implications: If the dam’s maternal care remains poor (e.g., she feeds them but isn’t interactive or is anxious), be aware that the puppies might not get the full benefit of maternal social learning. In such cases, it may help to introduce an additional stable adult dog into the equation once the pups are a bit older and if the mother permits. For instance, an “aunt” dog who likes puppies could supplement by playing or cuddling with them under supervision. If that’s not available, the breeder should spend extra time on puppy socialization exercises (lots of gentle play, perhaps more littermate interaction if there are multiple litters or a similarly aged litter they can mingle with after 4–5 weeks). Essentially, treat pups from an indifferent mother somewhat like orphans in terms of giving them extra social input.
• Watch for Maternal Behavior Problems: Occasionally, a C-section can result in truly disrupted maternal behavior – the dam might outright reject or fear her puppies. In those cases, prioritizing the puppies’ safety and care is paramount (hand-raise or find a foster mother). If the mother shows any inappropriate aggression or avoidance of the pups, involve a veterinarian or behaviorist for guidance. There may be hormone therapies or techniques to encourage acceptance (for example, supervised nursing while the mother is muzzled if she’s aggressive, though this is a last resort and very case-by-case). Do not force the issue if it’s clearly not working; instead, remove puppies and hand-rear to avoid trauma.

In summary, while C-section pups can grow up just as behaviorally healthy as naturally-born ones, the breeder must be vigilant in the first days to ensure they receive adequate maternal care or substitutes for it. Once nursing and bonding are established (or alternative care is in place), the subsequent stages of development (handling, socialization, etc.) proceed similarly to any other puppy. With prompt intervention and careful monitoring, the initial hiccups of a surgical birth can be overcome so that these puppies are not left behaviorally behind.

4. Expert Insights and Recommendations

To reinforce the above guidelines, here are insights from veterinary behavior specialists, researchers, and experienced breeders on optimizing puppy development:

• American Veterinary Society of Animal Behavior (AVSAB): The AVSAB emphasizes early socialization as a medical and behavioral imperative. “The primary and most important time for puppy socialization is the first three months of life… puppies should be exposed to as many new people, animals, stimuli and environments as can be achieved safely… [It] should be the standard of care for puppies to receive such socialization before they are fully vaccinated,” the society advises in a widely endorsed position statement (AVSAB Puppy Socialization Position Statement – Canine Welfare Science). AVSAB experts point out that because young puppies are primed to accept new experiences with minimal fear up until about 12 weeks, missing this window can lead to chronic fear and even aggression ( AVSAB Position Statement On Puppy Socialization vs Waiting to Complete Immunization: Dog Gone Problems). They also note that behavior problems stemming from inadequate early socialization are a top cause of death in dogs under 3 years (due to abandonment or euthanasia) ( AVSAB Position Statement On Puppy Socialization vs Waiting to Complete Immunization: Dog Gone Problems). Thus, veterinary behaviorists urge breeders and owners to prioritize safe social exposure (even attending puppy kindergarten by 8–10 weeks) over an excessive focus on disease avoidance ( AVSAB Position Statement On Puppy Socialization vs Waiting to Complete Immunization: Dog Gone Problems) ( AVSAB Position Statement On Puppy Socialization vs Waiting to Complete Immunization: Dog Gone Problems).
• Dr. John Paul Scott & Dr. John L. Fuller (Canine Behavioral Researchers): Scott and Fuller’s groundbreaking research in the 1950s–60s first described the canine developmental stages and the concept of a critical socialization period. They identified roughly 3 to 12 weeks as the phase when puppies form primary social attachments (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club). Their work demonstrated that pups isolated during this period showed serious social deficits, whereas those given even small amounts of social experience grew into well-adjusted pets. They famously stated that a “small amount of experience” at the right time can have a huge effect on later behavior (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club). Modern breeders continue to rely on their findings, ensuring puppies remain with littermates through at least 6–7 weeks to learn dog social skills, and get human contact starting early in the socialization window.
• Dr. Carmen Battaglia (Breeder and AKC Judge): Dr. Battaglia has popularized Early Neurological Stimulation (ENS) exercises for neonates, based on military canine program research. In a 2009 article, he summarizes that brief neurological challenges in days 3–16 can improve stress tolerance, disease resistance, and accelerate development in puppies (Nature Vs. Nurture). Battaglia’s program (“Super Dog” or “Bio Sensor”) involves handling newborns in specific ways (head up, head down, tickling feet, etc.). While some debate its extent of benefit, many breeders implement ENS as an easy, harmless way to potentially give puppies an edge. Battaglia also echoes that gentle early handling and enrichment lead to puppies that are “more socially confident and less fearful in new situations” (Nature Vs. Nurture). This insight aligns with other research (e.g., Gazzano et al. 2008) that showed early-handled pups were less fearful at 2 months . Breeders following Battaglia’s and others’ guidance have reported puppies adapting quickly to new homes and stresses, which they attribute to those neonatal exercises.
• Jane Killion (Breeder and Trainer, “Puppy Culture” program): Jane Killion advocates for an “intentional curriculum” for puppies from birth, something she outlines in her Puppy Culture videos and materials. She stresses that the third week of life (when senses activate) is a turning point: “Three weeks heralds the start of the crucial socialization period… it is important that puppies be kept primarily with their mother and littermates during this time… But this is also a good time to start removing the puppies for short periods for individual attention and positive interactions with humans,” Killion advises (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club) (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club). She demonstrates how providing different toys, surfaces, and mild challenges at this stage can prevent common anxieties (for instance, early exposure to various floorings can prevent a dog from being afraid to walk on shiny floors later (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club)). Killion is a proponent of startle-recovery training at 3–4 weeks, introducing sudden noises followed by treats or play, so puppies learn to bounce back quickly (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club). Many reputable breeders have adopted the Puppy Culture protocol, reporting that their puppies are notably confident, well-mannered, and easy to train – a strong testament to the power of structured early enrichment.
• Elaine Henley (Clinical Animal Behaviorist): In an article on breeders’ responsibilities in long-term canine behavioral health, Elaine Henley (2019) underscores that the breeder’s role is pivotal from day one. She highlights that prenatal stress in the mother can adversely affect puppies (citing studies in animals that maternal stress hormones influence offspring neurodevelopment) and that a breeder’s care should start even before birth by minimizing the dam’s stress. She also discusses how temperament is shaped in the first weeks, reinforcing that experiences (or lack thereof) during neonatal, transitional, and socialization periods can set a dog’s behavioral trajectory for life. One key point Henley makes is that breeders need to stay informed on current science and be proactive, rather than leaving all socialization to new owners. This expert perspective aligns with the idea that behavioral wellness is just as important as physical health in puppy raising.
• Dr. Ian Dunbar (Veterinarian & Behaviorist): Dr. Dunbar revolutionized puppy rearing with his insistence on early socialization and training. He famously suggests that puppies should meet 100 people by 12 weeks and experience all kinds of sights and sounds in a controlled way to maximize their social comfort. In his book “Before and After Getting Your Puppy,” Dunbar outlines how breeders and owners should systematically introduce pups to children, men, women, different ethnicities, people with hats, umbrellas, etc., making each encounter fun with treats and play. He also advocates for early bite inhibition training and handling exercises (cheekily noting that it’s much easier to habituate a 8-pound puppy to having its mouth handled than a 80-pound adult dog). Dr. Dunbar’s approach has been widely adopted in puppy classes worldwide. Many breeders summarize his philosophy as: socialization, socialization, socialization – as early as safely possible. This corroborates the positions of AVSAB and others that the risk of under-socialization is far more damaging than the controlled exposure risk prior to full vaccination.
• Scientific Community – Key Research Findings: Contemporary research continues to support these expert practices. For example, Pluijmakers et al. (2020) found that puppies who had “regular, positive contact with different people during the socialisation period” were significantly more confident around people as adults . Dietz et al. (2018) demonstrated that puppies raised in enriched environments with lots of stimuli and socialization showed better learning ability and fewer aggression/fear behaviors, whereas those from barren environments were more likely to develop fear or aggression issues . These studies, among others, give breeders evidence-based validation that what they do in the nest profoundly shapes behavioral outcomes.

In essence, expert consensus converges on a clear message: start early, go broad, and stay positive. From veterinary behaviorists to seasoned breeders, the advice is to expose puppies to the wide world in a controlled, happy manner from the time their eyes open. Breeders who follow this guidance are rewarded with puppies that handle new situations with aplomb, integrate easily into their new families, and have lower incidence of behavior problems. As Dr. Karen Overall (a veterinary behaviorist) succinctly put it: Through both responsible breeding and raising, it is possible to produce puppies that will successfully integrate into our lives (Nature Vs. Nurture).

5. Scientific References and Further Reading

Below is a selection of key studies and publications that support the best practices described above, for those interested in the scientific underpinnings of puppy development:

• Scott, J.P. & Fuller, J.L. (1965). Dog Behavior: The Genetic Basis. University of Chicago Press. – Classic research identifying developmental stages and the critical socialization window (3–12 weeks) in puppies. Demonstrated the lasting impact of early social experience on adult behavior. (Puppy Socialization Starts with the Breeder — The Crucial Third Week – American Kennel Club)
• Fox, M.W. (1978). The Dog: Its Domestication and Behavior. – Summarized early neurological development in puppies and the effects of early handling and social deprivation. Laid groundwork for understanding the neonatal sensory limitations and the importance of the transitional period.
• Battaglia, C.L. (2009). “Periods of Early Development and the Effects of Stimulation and Social Experiences in the Canine,” Journal of Veterinary Behavior 4(5): 203-210. – Explains the benefits of early neurological stimulation (ENS) and early socialization exercises. Reports that mildly stimulated neonates had improved cardiovascular performance, stronger adrenal glands, and greater stress tolerance. (Nature Vs. Nurture)
• Gazzano et al. (2008). Applied Animal Behaviour Science, (various studies by this group) – Investigated early handling in puppies. One study found that puppies handled by humans from days 3–21 showed less fear and were more exploratory at 8 weeks , supporting the practice of neonatal handling to enhance socialization.
• Pierantoni et al. (2011). “Evaluation of the behavioral effects of early separation from the mother and littermates in puppies,” Journal of Veterinary Behavior 6: 82-89. – Found that dogs separated from their litter at 30–40 days (4–5 weeks) exhibited more aggression, fear and attention-seeking behaviors compared to those separated at 2 months. Underscores that separating puppies too early can lead to long-term behavioral issues (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice).
• Foyer, P. et al. (2016). “Early experiences modulate stress coping in a population of German Shepherd dogs,” Applied Animal Behaviour Science 185: 93-101. – Showed that the quality of maternal care (nursing and licking frequency) and early rearing environment affected pups’ later stress responses and learning. This aligns with findings that high maternal care can produce more resilient, less anxious offspring (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice).
• Tiira, K. & Lohi, H. (2015). “Early life experiences and exercise associate with canine anxieties,” PLoS ONE 10(11): e0141907. – A survey-based study linking early life factors to noise phobias and separation anxieties in dogs. It suggested puppies that did not get enough social exposure or had traumatic early experiences were more prone to anxiety disorders. Also noted possible genetic predispositions, but environment was key. (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice)
• Pluijmakers, J. et al. (2020). “Regular petting during early socialization reduces separation anxiety and fear of strangers in dogs,” Vet Record 187: e17. – Recent study indicating puppies that had lots of positive human contact (20+ people) by 12 weeks were less likely to show fear of strangers as adults  . Reinforces the mantra that “more people = better” in early socialization.
• Dietz, L. et al. (2018). “Early life experiences and welfare of dogs – A review,” Journal of Veterinary Behavior 26: 13-20. – Comprehensive review of how prenatal factors, early handling, and socialization affect canine behavior. Cites that puppies in enriched environments (toys, complexity, social contacts) develop into more trainable, less fearful dogs  , whereas those in barren conditions risk developing severe behavior problems.
• Landsberg, G. et al. (2012). Behavior Problems of the Dog and Cat (3rd Ed.). – Veterinary behavior text that includes chapters on puppy development. Recommends early socialization practices and notes that a well-socialized puppy should meet dozens of people and experience many environments before 3 months  . Also reviews evidence that continued social exposure beyond 12 weeks is necessary to prevent regression .
• Overall, K. (2014). “Genetics and Behavior,” Vet Clinics of N. America: Small Animal Practice 44(3): 483-505. – Discusses how genetics intertwine with early environment in dogs. Emphasizes that even genetically sound puppies need appropriate socialization, and that behavioral issues often emerge from an interaction of predisposition and lack of proper early experiences. (Nature Vs. Nurture) (Nature Vs. Nurture)
• McAuliffe, L. (2021). “A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies,” Veterinary Practice (Sept 2021). – Article focusing on the challenges of orphaned and singleton puppies. Provides practical advice on fostering, simulating maternal care, and socializing such pups to prevent behavioral problems. Notes the heightened risk of issues like increased anxiety, poor bite inhibition, and attachment disorders in hand-reared pups (A behavioural perspective on hand-reared singleton puppies – Veterinary Practice) 

These references (and many others) consistently support the guidelines presented: that a combination of good genetics, low-stress prenatal and neonatal care, early gentle handling, rich environmental stimulation, ample socialization with people and other dogs, and continued training are the ingredients for a behaviorally healthy dog. Breeders who ground their practices in this science and expert advice are truly “raising” their puppies in the best sense – not just keeping them alive until sale, but cultivating stable, happy personalities that will enrich the lives of their future owners. By following the comprehensive approach outlined above, breeders can significantly reduce the likelihood of behavioral problems and increase the chances of their puppies growing into confident, adaptable, and well-mannered adult dogs.

If you are a breeder and have gotten this far into the article, you are the kind striving to turn out the best canine companions money can buy.  If you are not already being handsomely rewarded for such dedication, I strongly recommend you watch the free 1-hour online breeder masterclass where I show breeders dedicated to raising the perfect puppy how to market themselves effectively.  Grab your spot here.